When the Western Reserve was finally opened up to exploration and settlement in 1796, the settlers met with no Indian resistance. The Treaty of Greenville of 1795 removed all Indian claims to the Western Reserve portion lying east of the Cuyahoga.
Those brave souls who set out from Connecticut, Massachusetts, New York and New Jersey and other areas knew they faced forests with no paths, ranges of mountains, wild animals, swift rivers that must be forded and sandy lake shores that stretched from their well-established Connecticut homes to the wild Western Reserve.
According to an early settlement essay written by former Windsor resident, W.D. Loomis, in 1989, “a fine place for men and dogs, but a bad place for women and horses,” would hold true for the venture men took with their young families to explore this area.
Smith had moved from Massachusetts to Millsford (first name for Dorset) in 1818, bringing his wife and young son. They were among the first settlers in Millsford. They built a cabin and cleared the heavy growth of original forest. By 1830, the Smiths had built a brick home using the very bricks they had made themselves. Beside their home, they built a saw mill by a small stream, and later, a cider mill close by, possibly the first in the township.
The couple’s first daughter, Mary, born in 1820, was the first white child born in Dorset. She would recall from her youth that she was out picking berries one day from a bush when she discovered a bear was on the other side picking berries also!
Unfortunately, the name of John Smith’s wife is not mentioned in any of the information I researched. But the brave young woman bore nine children, six of whom reached a mature age, but all had died by 1913 except the two youngest, Pomeroy and Rufus.
Early Dorset settler Austin Burr left his home in Ludlow, Hampden County, Massachusetts, in 1799. In 1822, he moved from Oneida County, New York, to Madison, Ohio, in Lake County. In 1824, he bought a piece of land from John Smith in Dorset.
Perhaps these men knew each other before they left Massachusetts, but when they reached Dorset, they became two of the first landowners in Dorset. He built his log cabin on the south side of the road a few rods west of the place that became known as the Giles Slater place.
Burr was a cooper by trade, which means he made barrels. Two years later, he married Miss Sarah Houghton at her home in Andover in 1826. I have often wondered how young people met someone to marry in those early days of settlement when there were no roads, businesses, churches or close neighbors!
Miss Houghton was intelligent and loved to teach. She had been teaching at the first Dorset School since 1823, a year before she married. She had 16 students in one classroom and received 75 cents a week or $9 per term.
To show the strength of Sarah Houghton, one need only look at how she got to school. She came from her home in Andover on horseback seated behind the school director. The cabin in which the school was taught was situated near the site of the Thorp family cabin and “very near the south line of the land now owned by Lewis Arner and about twenty rods east of where the said line crosses Bassett Creek,” according to historical records.
The only road between Dorset and Andover at that time consisted of a bridle path which ran along the north-easternly side of the “Marsh” or “Swamp” that was near W.H. Bailey property.
The “Marsh” was known for its wild huckle berries and an immense crop of Massauga rattlesnakes. They do not get very long as far as rattlers go, but they were about as thick as a man’s wrist and about two- and one-half feet long for the largest, down to the size of a lead pencil.
The Burr family was used to danger and knowing the risk from the Massauga rattlesnakes, still worked barefoot in the hayfield. But one day, young John Burr stepped on a good size snake but avoided being bitten. They wore their shoes after that close call.
Cabins were used for schools in Dorset until the year of 1846 or 1848. But the young teacher, Sarah Houghton, was now Sarah Burr and her days in the schoolroom were over. She bore seven children named Charles, Mary, Elmina, Lydia, John, Rufus and Cornelia.
One day, Sarah heard their dog barking incessantly and went to find out what was the problem. Walking down to the creek, she discovered a deer the dog was holding at bay. She seized a pole and “dispatched the deer at once,” knowing it would provide food for her family and a skin for a rug or blanket. All in a day’s work for a settler.
Sarah would live to see the first school building open its doors to students in either 1846 or 1848. It was located at the point where the Hayes Road intersects the east and west road and just east of what became known as Burgett’s or Peter’s Corners. Five schools would eventually be opened to Dorset students.
Husband Austin Burr became the Justice of the Peace and had the honor of marrying the first couple to get hitched in Dorset. The Widow Sutliff married a Mr. Griffin.
The early settlers would recall the musical performances they heard every night that came from the howls of bears, wolves and coyotes.
Rufus F. and John H. Burr would grow into young men and serve in the Civil War. While serving in Kentucky at Fort Boyle in 1863, Rufus wrote letters to their sister, Elmina Burr Miller of New Lyme. She had married Deacon Joseph Miller, Jr. Copies of two of these letters are available to read at the Jefferson Historical Society. John Burr also wrote his sister from War Department Barracks in Washington, D.C. in 1865.
He wrote her right after the assassination of President Lincoln. His description of what he saw when he went into the rotunda of the White House gives a local firsthand look at a national tragedy for our nation and worth including here. “On Wednesday last I went to the White House and looked for the last time on what remained of President Lincoln as he lay in state. His coffin was decorated in the most exquisite style with heavy silver trimming and flowers. The funeral procession, as it moved from the White House to the capitol on the following day, presented a grand and impressive scene. It surpassed anything that had ever happened before in the city.”
The letters and the family picture with this column, along with the 1820 spinning wheel that came with Austin Burr in 1820, are available to view at the society building. They were donated by Charles A. Burr’s great-great granddaughter, Noreen Martin of Andover.
Austin and Sarah Burr donated the land for the Hayes Cemetery in Dorset. Much of the information in this column was taken from a 1913 newspaper called “The Dorset Hustler,” which was printed once a week.
Support authors and subscribe to content
This is premium stuff. Subscribe to read the entire article.




































